Methods for Trophic Ecology Assessment in Fishes: A Critical Review of Stomach Analyses

Assessment of fish trophic ecology in natural environments is imperative to understand biological and ecological requirements, supporting the management and conservation of populations and environments. There are several methods available to assess fish diets, generically divided in noninvasive approaches, such as underwater observations, and invasive approaches, such as analyses of lipid biomarkers, stable isotopes and stomach contents. Each one has application assumptions and conditions that must be aligned with study objectives and methodological criteria, assuring results robustness and allowing comparability among different studies. This review addresses the advantages and limitations of these methods, highlighting those applied for stomach analysis (SA). This work presents complete updated review concerning qualitative and quantitative methods applied to SA: sixty equations were reviewed comprising four formulae to value stomachs per se and, for stomach content analysis, eight single indices, fifteen composite indices and thirty-three equations related to modeling approaches. The review presents different potentialities associated to these methods, standardizes distinct names applied to a same method, and provides clarifications on confusion sources due to the use of same names in distinct methods, a source of scientific mistakes detected in the specialized literature.